Can AI Predict Your Breakup? The Dilemma of Love, Data, and Agency

In partnership with

Your daily AI dose

Mindstream is your one-stop shop for all things AI.

How good are we? Well, we become only the second ever newsletter (after the Hustle) to be acquired by HubSpot. Our small team of writers works hard to put out the most enjoyable and informative newsletter on AI around.

It’s completely free, and you’ll get a bunch of free AI resources when you subscribe.

Click here to subscribe

You and Alex have been together for years, sharing laughter, dreams, and a vision of the future. Recently, the topic of engagement has come up. While Alex is enthusiastic, you can’t shake off a nagging fear—what if it doesn’t last? You’ve seen the statistics: over 10% of first marriages end in divorce within five years, often leaving bitterness and regret in their wake.

But this isn’t your typical modern-day scenario. In the near future, you have access to a revolutionary AI tool. This AI claims to predict your likelihood of divorce with an impressive 95% accuracy by analyzing vast data from your life: social media activity, search history, spending habits, and even patterns of past marital outcomes.

The verdict is delivered with stark simplicity: You will or won’t divorce within five years of marriage. However, it offers no explanation—no insight into why it made that prediction or what factors led to its decision.

Now the question is: Would you let this prediction decide your future?

The Choices Before You

Suppose the AI predicts that you and Alex will divorce within five years. What should you do?

1. Go ahead and get married. You might choose to trust your love and hope the AI’s prediction is wrong. After all, it’s just a model, not destiny.

2. Break up now. If the AI’s prediction carries enough weight for you, it could lead to ending your currently happy relationship—perhaps prematurely.

3. Stay together but don’t get married. Maybe you’ll consider skipping marriage entirely, believing the institution itself might be the issue. However, without understanding why the prediction was made, you’d never know if the same underlying issues would still affect your relationship even without tying the knot.

Each choice is fraught with uncertainty. You’re left wondering whether the AI truly understands the complexities of your relationship or if its prediction has blinded you to other possibilities.

The Problem with AI Predictions

This dilemma highlights a significant limitation of current AI systems: a lack of transparency and explainability. While the AI might achieve high accuracy, it operates as a black box, providing answers without justification.

This isn’t unique to predicting relationships—it’s a widespread issue in AI across industries. Predictive models are already used to determine:

• Loan approvals: Which applicants are most likely to repay.

• Criminal justice decisions: Which prisoners are most likely to reoffend if granted parole.

• Hiring: Which candidates are likely to succeed in a given role.

However, these decisions often lack clarity. Without knowing why an AI makes a particular prediction, users are left to blindly trust—or completely disregard—the output.

This lack of transparency doesn’t just create confusion; it also leads to ethical dilemmas. For instance, if you broke up with Alex based on the AI’s prediction, what explanation could you give them? “The AI said so” feels inadequate and unfair, especially when the relationship is currently happy and thriving.

The Tradeoff: Accuracy vs. Authenticity

The decision to rely on an AI prediction comes down to your priorities:

1. If you prioritize accuracy, you might trust the AI’s prediction and act accordingly, even if it feels impersonal. You could argue that avoiding a doomed marriage is better than enduring the emotional and financial toll of divorce.

2. If you value authenticity, you might want to understand why the AI made its prediction before deciding. Authentic decision-making involves reflecting on your unique circumstances and emotions—not just statistical probabilities.

Authenticity also leaves room for hope. Remember, 95% accuracy still means 1 in 20 predictions is wrong. You could be the exception that proves the rule.

The Risk of Self-Fulfilling Prophecies

There’s another unsettling possibility: what if the AI’s prediction causes its own accuracy?

Imagine a couple that’s happy but unsure. Upon hearing a negative prediction, they begin to doubt each other. Those doubts spark conflicts, and the relationship deteriorates. In the end, they break up—not because of inherent incompatibility, but because the AI planted a seed of distrust.

As more people use such AI systems, these self-fulfilling prophecies could artificially inflate their success rates. Instead of reflecting reality, the AI might start shaping it, undermining the very accuracy it claims to achieve.

The Power of Choice

Ultimately, the AI can only make a prediction—it can’t make your decisions for you. The choice to use the tool, and how much weight to give its results, is entirely yours.

This brings us to a deeper question: Should you rely on AI to make such a profoundly personal decision? Relationships are built on trust, communication, and shared experiences—factors that are inherently human and difficult to quantify.

An AI might provide insight, but it can’t account for the complexities of love, resilience, and personal growth. Sometimes, defying the odds and proving the predictions wrong is what makes a relationship truly meaningful.

A Thought Experiment for the Future

The idea of an AI predicting your breakup might feel far-fetched, but it raises important questions about how we integrate AI into our lives:

• How much should we rely on data to guide personal decisions?

• What happens when predictions become self-fulfilling?

• Can we maintain our humanity in the face of cold, statistical analysis?

In the end, whether you choose to trust the AI or follow your heart, remember this: relationships are more than just probabilities. They are about commitment, effort, and the courage to face uncertainty together.

So, if you and Alex were in this situation, what would you do? Would you let AI define your future, or would you take the risk and embrace the unpredictability of love?