OPENAI:😱 OpenAI’s Sora video model leaked

In partnership with

Your daily AI dose

Mindstream is your one-stop shop for all things AI.

How good are we? Well, we become only the second ever newsletter (after the Hustle) to be acquired by HubSpot. Our small team of writers works hard to put out the most enjoyable and informative newsletter on AI around.

It’s completely free, and you’ll get a bunch of free AI resources when you subscribe.

Click here to subscribe

OpenAI’s much-anticipated text-to-video AI tool, Sora, has become the center of a controversy after a group of artists testing the technology leaked details in protest. The incident, which unfolded on the developer platform Hugging Face, underscores growing tensions between creators and AI companies as generative technology evolves.

Sora, designed to transform text into videos, represents a leap forward in artificial intelligence capabilities. However, this potential disrupts industries reliant on human creativity, such as filmmaking and animation, raising ethical and economic concerns.

What Happened?

The leak occurred when a project on Hugging Face linked to the Sora application programming interface (API) surfaced, allowing external users to test the model. Alongside this, several testers uploaded a strongly-worded open letter accusing OpenAI of exploiting their labor. These testers, referring to themselves as “PR Puppets,” alleged that the company used them for unpaid work under the guise of feedback and experimental testing.

OpenAI quickly shut down access to the API, and the letter was removed. However, the artists’ concerns reflect broader dissatisfaction with how early testing programs, known as “redteaming,” are being conducted.

The letter highlighted issues with OpenAI’s approach, stating:

The testers claimed that only minimal compensation was provided, and some incentives, such as competitions for film screenings, were insufficient to justify the time and effort required.

Concerns from the Creative Industry

Sora’s capabilities have raised alarms among creative professionals. Its ability to generate high-quality videos from simple text inputs threatens to replace jobs in animation, visual effects, and even film direction. OpenAI has been showcasing Sora to Hollywood executives in an effort to promote collaboration and address these concerns.

However, skepticism remains high. Last month, over 11,000 creative professionals, including prominent actors like Julianne Moore and Kevin Bacon, musicians such as Radiohead’s Thom Yorke, and a range of writers and visual artists, signed an open letter warning against the unchecked rise of generative AI. The letter labeled these technologies as “a major, unjust threat” to livelihoods, highlighting the disparity between the promises of AI innovation and the potential damage to human careers.

The Artists’ Perspective

The artists involved in testing Sora see themselves at the center of this debate. While they acknowledge the transformative power of AI, they feel sidelined in the development process.

The leaked letter accused OpenAI of “artwashing” — using artists’ labor to lend credibility to the tool’s development while downplaying its risks. Artists argue that OpenAI’s redteaming efforts are more focused on public relations than genuine collaboration, reducing their role to that of unpaid contributors.

They also noted a lack of transparency in how their feedback was used and expressed frustration at being required to keep the details confidential while OpenAI capitalized on their efforts.

OpenAI’s Response

In response to the backlash, OpenAI emphasized that the testing program was voluntary and designed for research purposes only. A company spokesperson stated that participants were under no obligation to provide feedback and that confidentiality was a standard requirement for any early-stage project.

OpenAI further clarified that Sora remains in preview mode, with no definitive timeline for public release. The company is reportedly focused on addressing safety concerns, refining the tool’s accuracy, and scaling the necessary computing power to ensure the tool operates effectively on a larger scale.

Kevin Weil, OpenAI’s chief product officer, recently commented on Reddit that delays in Sora’s release were partly due to the company’s efforts to “perfect the model” and balance its creative capabilities with robust safety measures.

A Growing Divide

The Sora controversy is emblematic of a broader divide between the tech sector and the creative industries. While AI promises to democratize creativity, enabling individuals to produce professional-grade content with minimal resources, it also raises existential questions for artists, filmmakers, and designers.

For OpenAI, the challenge lies in ensuring its tools benefit society without marginalizing the very communities they aim to support. However, for many in the creative industry, the road ahead appears fraught with uncertainty.

As Sora moves closer to a potential public release, it is likely to face continued scrutiny from both creators and policymakers. The incident serves as a reminder that while AI can enable groundbreaking innovations, its development must prioritize fairness, transparency, and inclusivity to avoid alienating those most affected by its adoption.