The Hidden Autopilot Data That Reveals Why Teslas Crash

In partnership with

The future of presentations, powered by AI

Gamma’s AI creates beautiful presentations, websites, and more. No design or coding skills required. Try it free today.

On the quiet morning of May 5th, 2021, 35-year-old Steven Hendrickson set out on his daily commute in his Tesla Model 3. It was a routine drive on Southern California’s highways, one he had made countless times before. With Tesla’s Autopilot engaged, Steven trusted the advanced driver-assist system to take over the mundane aspects of driving, freeing him to relax behind the wheel.

But at 2:30 AM, everything changed.

An overturned semi-truck lay across the Fontana freeway. With no apparent warning or response from the Autopilot system, Steven’s Model 3 slammed into the truck at highway speeds. The impact was fatal.

Steven’s death left behind a devastated family—his wife, Janell, and two young children. For them, Tesla’s promise of safety and convenience had turned into a tragedy.

This wasn’t an isolated incident.

Since mid-2021, Tesla has reported over 1,000 crashes involving its Autopilot system to federal regulators. Among these, The Wall Street Journal analyzed data from 222 cases, uncovering a chilling pattern of failures:

• Failure to detect stopped vehicles: A recurring issue where Teslas using Autopilot crash into stationary objects, such as emergency vehicles, trailers, or debris on the road.

• Sudden veering: Instances where Teslas inexplicably veer off course, often into barriers or other vehicles.

• Overreliance by drivers: Many drivers assumed Autopilot could fully take over, leading to lapses in attention.

These failures have resulted in dozens of deaths and severe injuries, raising questions about Tesla’s technology and the level of trust it inspires in its users.

The Camera-Only Gamble

While other autonomous driving systems, such as those by Waymo or GM’s Cruise, rely on a combination of sensors—including radar and lidar—Tesla has bet heavily on a camera-only approach. This decision, driven by cost-cutting and Elon Musk’s belief in “vision over sensors,” makes Tesla’s system prone to errors in real-world scenarios.

For example:

• Overturned trucks and stopped vehicles are often misclassified or entirely ignored.

• Emergency vehicles with flashing lights frequently confuse the system, leading to collisions.

• Low-light or adverse weather conditions exacerbate these limitations, making the system less reliable at night or in heavy rain.

Tesla continues to claim that Autopilot reduces accidents by significant margins, but regulators and experts argue that the company has not provided transparent or independent data to substantiate these claims.

Lives at Stake

For families like Steven Hendrickson’s, these crashes aren’t just numbers—they’re heartbreaking losses. Steven’s widow, Janell, is among many families suing Tesla, alleging that its marketing gave drivers a false sense of security. “He trusted Autopilot with his life and our kids’ lives. I have to explain to my children why their dad isn’t coming home,” Janell said in a recent interview.

The WSJ investigation sheds light on more troubling trends:

• Regulatory gaps: U.S. safety agencies, like the NHTSA, have been slow to enforce strict oversight on Autopilot’s development and Tesla’s marketing claims.

• Consumer overconfidence: Tesla drivers often misuse Autopilot, believing it is closer to full self-driving capability than it actually is—a misunderstanding fueled by Tesla’s branding and lack of adequate disclaimers.

• Lack of accountability: Tesla is under investigation by the Department of Justice for potentially misleading consumers about the capabilities of Autopilot and its Full Self-Driving (FSD) system.

The Future of Tesla’s Self-Driving Promise

Despite mounting criticism and lawsuits, Tesla continues to double down on its vision of full autonomy, even as the timeline for achieving it keeps slipping. Meanwhile, real lives are being lost in the gap between marketing promises and technological reality.

Tesla’s stock and reputation ride on the idea of Autopilot as a transformative safety feature. But as data from these crashes continues to surface, it forces a critical question: Is Tesla’s gamble on Autopilot worth the human cost?